Jimmy's Famous Seafood Reviews
Jimmy's Famous Seafood has an overall rating of 4.4 based on 64 reviews. Customer feedback on Jimmy's Famous Seafood is mixed: Jimmy's Famous Seafood reviewers highlight positive aspects like fresh seafood, excellent customer service, generous portions, great atmosphere, which strongly appeal to seafood lovers, families, foodies, tourists. However, Jimmy's Famous Seafood is often criticized for its high prices, long wait times, inconsistent quality, limited parking.
64 reviews
5 Stars
8
4 Stars
1
3 Stars
0
2 Stars
2
1 Star
0
How would you rate Jimmy's Famous Seafood?
All Jimmy's Famous Seafood Reviews (64)
hello_tammy316
May 30, 2026
"Pretty good packaging, still cold on arrival"
I was a little unsure about ordering at first because I was worried it wouldn’t stay cold, but it actually showed up in good shape. Everything was packed well, the ice packs were still mostly frozen, and there weren’t any leaks in the box. It did take me a bit longer to unpack than I expected, but that’s not a big deal. Overall, I’m happy with how it arrived.
0
Reply
adelinearnold0765
April 01, 2026
"The food looked decent when it came out..."
The food looked decent when it came out, but whoever’s in charge of flavor really missed the mark. The crab cakes barely tasted like anything, and the fries were just average at best. I was expecting a lot better, and it’s frustrating to pay for a meal that ends up being this bland...
0
Reply
carriegage4863
April 01, 2026
"Pretty good deal for seafood"
Grabbed food from Jimmy’s and yeah, for the price it was decent. The portions were solid and the seafood tasted fresh, which is always a win. It’s not like super cheap or anything, but for a little treat meal, I’d say it was worth it.
0
Reply
leona-Ferguson
March 24, 2026
"The food was fine when it finally..."
The food was fine when it finally showed up, but the delivery took way too long. They kept giving vague updates like it would be there “soon,” which just made it more annoying. I would’ve appreciated a real estimate instead of empty promises.
0
Reply
elvira_Sims02
March 12, 2026
"Went to Jimmy’s Famous Seafood with my family..."
Went to Jimmy’s Famous Seafood with my family and had a really nice time. The place was busy, but the whole process was easy from getting settled in to ordering, and it never felt overwhelming.
It had a fun local feel with lots of people clearly enjoying themselves. The staff was relaxed, friendly, and kept things moving without making us feel rushed.
We felt comfortable the whole time, and the atmosphere was just right for a casual seafood night. I’d definitely go back again.
It had a fun local feel with lots of people clearly enjoying themselves. The staff was relaxed, friendly, and kept things moving without making us feel rushed.
We felt comfortable the whole time, and the atmosphere was just right for a casual seafood night. I’d definitely go back again.
0
Reply
AnaHurwitz
March 03, 2026
"Really fresh seafood, in my opinion"
I ordered from Jimmy’s Famous Seafood, i was impressed. The seafood tasted really fresh to me, especially the crab, which had a nice flavor and none of that overly fishy smell that can sometimes be a red flag. Everything showed up cold and packed well, so my take was that it had been handled properly and definitely wasn’t just sitting around for ages. Overall, I was really happy with the order and would absolutely get it again
0
Reply
rickey.Davenport
February 19, 2026
"Best crab cakes I’ve had"
Wow. These crab cakes were seriously so good. Fresh, flavorful, and just really satisfying. Delicious
0
Reply
rosemary_Bender77
February 16, 2026
"Wait was totally reasonable"
I went in figuring there might be a bit of a wait, which is kind of expected when a place is busy, but it moved faster than I thought it would. The staff seemed to have a good system going, and we were seated quickly. Food came out in a normal amount of time too. Overall, everything went smoothly and I really can’t complain...
0
Reply
ValarieShrum
December 18, 2025
"Order was right, which honestly helped restore a little trust"
I’ve had a few recent orders from other places get messed up, so I was starting to feel skeptical. This one came exactly as I asked, and everything was right. Simple, but it definitely made me feel a bit better about ordering again. Thanks.
0
Reply
Jana.bryant
December 14, 2025
"Huge portions, seriously"
The portions here are no joke. I ordered thinking it’d be a normal meal, but I ended up with enough leftovers for lunch the next day. I’m usually a little wary when places talk themselves up, and I don’t always trust customer service to be straight with you, but the food actually delivered. Totally worth it.
0
Reply
RobertHobson
December 13, 2025
"I had a small issue with my order..."
I had a small issue with my order, and they got it sorted out quickly. It was a smooth experience overall, so I appreciated the help.
0
Reply
Have a question about Jimmy's Famous Seafood?
Log in to ask your Jimmy's Famous Seafood question!
Customer Reviews
Ask a Question
